Tele: 561.316.3330
Breaking Medical Device News

Monday, September 27, 2021

HomeDatascope CorpDatascope Moves To Join Maquet's Patent Infringement Case Against Abiomed In Order To Add False Advertising Claims

Datascope Moves To Join Maquet’s Patent Infringement Case Against Abiomed In Order To Add False Advertising Claims


Datascope alleges Abiomed made intentional false comparisons between Abiomed’s Impella® and Datascope’s IABP; Maquet alleges that many Impella® models infringe six Maquet patents

Datascope Corp. today announced the filing of a motion to join Maquet Cardiovascular LLC’s existing patent infringement case against Abiomed, Inc. in the federal court for the District of Massachusetts, to assert counterclaims alleging that Abiomed has engaged in false advertising by promoting its Impella® device as superior to Datascope’s intra-aortic balloon pumps (IABPs). Simultaneously, Maquet is expanding its infringement case by alleging that most Impella® models infringe three patents issued to Maquet this year, thus bringing the total number of patents in the suit to six. Both Datascope and Maquet are Getinge companies.

Datascope is a leading manufacturer of IABPs, which are circulatory assist devices that use counterpulsation to help the heart pump blood in patients in need of cardiac support. Abiomed’s Impella® is a ventricular assist device used for mechanical circulatory support.

Datascope’s counterclaims assert that Abiomed has engaged in a pattern of intentional and widespread false advertising regarding Impella® compared with IABP in violation of federal and state law. According to the lawsuit, Abiomed has falsely advertised that the PROTECT II trial, which was terminated for futility and was underpowered, and a related “hypothesis-generating” post hoc analysis of the PROTECT II data, demonstrate that Impella® significantly reduces major adverse events compared with IABP at 90 days. Datascope alleges that Abiomed’s marketing materials are false.

Datascope’s counterclaims also identify recent developments to support Datascope’s position that Abiomed’s superiority claims are unlawful. An example is Health Quality Ontario’s February 2017 in-depth technology assessment, which concludes that “percutaneous ventricular support with Impella does not lower death rates; nor is it safer or cheaper than usual treatment with balloon pumps.”1Another example is the October 2016 explorative, randomized, controlled IMPRESS trial, sponsored by Abiomed, which concludes that routine treatment with Impella CP was not associated with reduced 30-day mortality compared with IABP.2

In addition, Datascope alleges that Abiomed disseminated false representations regarding U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of IABP, the cost-effectiveness of Impella® compared with IABP, the standard of care, and other features of Impella®. According to the lawsuit, Abiomed advertises that IABP is not FDA-approved as safe and effective for the treatment of acute myocardial infarction, cardiogenic shock, or for use during high-risk PCI. The counterclaims state that IABP has, in fact, been designated as a Class II device and that a 2012 FDA review found that IABP offers a reasonable assurance of safety and effectiveness for these indications.

In 2016, Maquet asserted that many Impella® models infringe three Maquet patents entitled “Guidable Intravascular Blood Pump And Related Methods”. Earlier this year, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office issued three more patents to Maquet in this area; Maquet is adding the three new patents to the case. Maquet asserts that all six patents relate to significant technological developments that Abiomed improperly incorporated in many of its Impella® products, for which Maquet is entitled to just compensation.

Medical Device News Magazine
Medical Device News Magazine is a division of PTM Healthcare Marketing, Inc. Pauline T. Mayer is the managing editor.

Stay Connected


Don't Miss

ProSomnus® Sleep Technologies Adds John E. Remmers, MD, to Leadership Team

Dr. John E. Remmers will provide expert medical and strategic guidance on a range of initiatives, including research and development, regulatory clearances, company strategy, medical education, and clinical investigations.

Nanox to Announce Zebra Medical Vision Secures 8th 510K FDA Clearance for its Coronary Artery Calcium (CAC) Solution as Part of Its Population Health Offering

On August 10th, 2021 Nanox announced that it had entered into an acquisition agreement via merger with Zebra Medical Vision LTD.

Christopher Joyce Joins Miach Orthopaedics as VP & CFO

Christopher Joyce has joined as vice president and chief financial officer, and Kevin Sidow has been appointed to the company’s board of directors.

NGMedical GmbH Receives FDA Clearance for Its AM Titanium Lumbar Interbody BEE® PLIF

The BEE® PLIF cage has been created to benefit from additive manufacturing features. The purposefully designed honeycomb endplate design reduces the risk of subsidence, while allowing fusion.

Tyber Medical Reaches Agreement to Acquire CatapultMD

Once the acquisition is complete, Tyber Medical will own and operate a combined 100,000-square feet of manufacturing space between its Pennsylvania headquarters and Florida-based facilities.

Kleiner Device Labs Receives FDA Market Clearance for KG2 Surge Flow-Thru Interbody System

The system maximizes total bone graft delivery volume, better distributes graft bilaterally into the intervertebral disc space, and streamlines the implant delivery, positioning, and grafting process for TLIF and PLIF spinal fusion procedures.

By using this website you agree to accept Medical Device News Magazine Privacy Policy